MTSU (Naveen "Scott" Pejaver Debates) Sept 27-29 2002 Middle Tennessee State University Elim results for OPEN Finals: Mercer BeCi defeats Alabama PhGr 2-1 Semis: Alabama PhGr advances over Alabama ScCo without a debate. Semis: Mercer BeCi defeats Alabama SmAl 2-1 Elim results for JV Elim results for Nov Finals: Vandy CrMa advances over Vandy FlRy without a debate. Semis: Vandy FlRy advances over Vandy PaSp without a debate. Semis: Vandy CrMa defeats Capital MoMo 2-1 Quarters: Vandy FlRy defeats Capital NaBa 2-1 Quarters: Vandy CrMa defeats MiaFL CaZw 2-1 Quarters: Capital MoMo defeats Vandy PeHa 3-0 Quarters: Vandy PaSp defeats AppSt HeTo 3-0 Elim results for Rookie Mercer Ruth Beerman & David Cisneros 1 OPEN Neg Campbell, Br WIN Vandy StOl 27.0 2 27.0 1 2 OPEN AFF Beaulieu, Br WIN L'Ville BeHe 30.0 1 29.0 2 3 OPEN AFF Schaerrer, M LOSS Alabama PhGr 27.0 3 27.0 4 4 OPEN Neg Bond, Terran WIN Alabama WyGo 28.0 2 28.5 1 5 OPEN AFF Steinberg, D WIN Alabama SmAl 28.0 1 27.0 3 6 OPEN Neg Miller, Davi WIN Alabama ScCo 29.0 1 28.0 2 Semis AFF:Alabama SmAl NEG:Mercer BeCi Grindy, Matt(AFF) Ellinger, Nick(NEG) Bond, Terrance(NEG) Finals: AFF:Alabama PhGr NEG:Mercer BeCi Unknown(NEG) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Mercer Brandi Gaylor & Sarah Wright 1 OPEN AFF Miller, Davi WIN Alabama MyEv 25.0 3 26.0 1 2 OPEN Neg Gaston, Brya LOSS Alabama SmAl 27.0 3 27.0 4 3 OPEN Neg Beaulieu, Br LOSS Alabama ScCo 26.0 4 29.0 1 4 OPEN AFF Ellinger, Ni LOSS Ga St. BlCr 27.0 2 26.0 4 5 OPEN AFF Crews, Danie WIN Ga St. CoCr 28.0 2 28.0 1 6 OPEN Neg Steinberg, D WIN L'Ville BeHe 27.0 3 27.0 1 Alabama Meagan Myers & Marques Evans 1 OPEN Neg Miller, Davi LOSS Mercer GaWr 24.0 4 26.0 2 2 OPEN AFF Ellinger, Ni WIN Ga St. CoCr 27.0 3 27.5 1 3 OPEN AFF Brooks, S LOSS Clemson LeJo 28.0 3 28.0 2 4 OPEN Neg Butler, Drew WIN Vandy ThMa 27.0 2 28.0 1 5 OPEN Neg Abbott, Blak WIN Ga St. BlCr 27.0 2 27.0 1 6 OPEN AFF Schaerrer, M WIN TennTechWhCa 28.0 1 28.0 2 Alabama Brandon Scott & Micheal Collins 1 OPEN AFF Butler, Drew WIN Ga St. BlCr 27.0 1 26.0 2 2 OPEN Neg Whitmore, Wh WIN Clemson LeJo 27.0 1 27.0 2 3 OPEN AFF Beaulieu, Br WIN Mercer GaWr 27.0 3 28.0 2 4 OPEN Neg Dillard, Tif LOSS Capital PiKo 29.0 2 30.0 1 5 OPEN Neg Ellinger, Ni WIN Capital RaJo 28.5 2 28.5 1 6 OPEN AFF Miller, Davi LOSS Mercer BeCi 27.5 3 27.5 4 Semis close-out; no debate. Alabama Heather Wyatt & Lisa Gonzalez 1 OPEN Neg Schaerrer, M WIN Vandy BoLi 27.5 1 27.5 2 2 OPEN AFF Grindy, Matt WIN Capital RaJo 29.0 2 29.0 1 3 OPEN Neg Abbott, Blak WIN MiaFL ToRa 27.5 1 27.0 2 4 OPEN AFF Bond, Terran LOSS Mercer BeCi 27.0 4 27.0 3 5 OPEN AFF Burch, Daryl LOSS Clemson LeJo 26.5 4 27.0 3 6 OPEN Neg Brooks, S WIN Capital PiKo 28.0 1 27.0 2 Alabama Tameka Phillips & Bryan Grayson 1 OPEN Neg Brooks, S WIN Capital RaJo 30.0 2 30.0 1 2 OPEN AFF Dillard, Tif WIN Vandy ThMa 30.0 1 29.0 2 3 OPEN Neg Schaerrer, M WIN Mercer BeCi 27.5 2 27.5 1 4 OPEN AFF Campbell, Br WIN MiaFL ToRa 29.0 1 29.0 2 5 OPEN AFF Whitmore, Wh WIN Capital PiKo 27.5 1 27.5 2 6 OPEN Neg Ellinger, Ni WIN Clemson LeJo 28.5 2 29.0 1 Semis close-out; no debate. Finals: AFF:Alabama PhGr NEG:Mercer BeCi Unknown(NEG) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Alabama Abi Smith & Ashley Al-sayyed 1 OPEN Neg Young, Lynds WIN TennTechWhCa 28.5 2 28.5 1 2 OPEN AFF Gaston, Brya WIN Mercer GaWr 28.0 2 28.5 1 3 OPEN AFF Ellinger, Ni WIN Capital PiKo 27.0 2 28.0 1 4 OPEN Neg Beaulieu, Br LOSS Clemson LeJo 29.0 1 28.0 2 5 OPEN Neg Steinberg, D LOSS Mercer BeCi 27.0 4 27.0 2 6 OPEN AFF Burch, Daryl WIN Ga St. BlCr 28.0 1 27.5 2 Semis AFF:Alabama SmAl NEG:Mercer BeCi Grindy, Matt(AFF) Ellinger, Nick(NEG) Bond, Terrance(NEG) Capital Lauren Raymer & Mike Jones 1 OPEN AFF Brooks, S LOSS Alabama PhGr 28.0 3 27.0 4 2 OPEN Neg Grindy, Matt LOSS Alabama WyGo 26.0 3 26.0 4 3 OPEN AFF Butler, Drew WIN Vandy BoLi 27.0 1 26.0 2 4 OPEN Neg Abbott, Blak WIN L'Ville BeHe 27.5 1 27.0 2 5 OPEN AFF Ellinger, Ni LOSS Alabama ScCo 27.0 3 27.0 4 6 OPEN Neg Herndon, Jam LOSS Vandy ThMa 27.0 3 27.0 4 Capital Chris Piazza & John Koch 1 OPEN Neg Burch, Daryl WIN Vandy ThMa 27.0 2 27.0 1 2 OPEN AFF Young, Lynds WIN Vandy BoLi 28.0 2 28.5 1 3 OPEN Neg Ellinger, Ni LOSS Alabama SmAl 26.0 3 26.0 4 4 OPEN AFF Dillard, Tif WIN Alabama ScCo 27.0 3 27.0 4 5 OPEN Neg Whitmore, Wh LOSS Alabama PhGr 27.0 4 27.0 3 6 OPEN AFF Brooks, S LOSS Alabama WyGo 27.0 4 27.0 3 Clemson Justin Ledbetter & Brandon Jordan 1 OPEN Neg Abbott, Blak WIN Ga St. CoCr 27.0 2 27.0 1 2 OPEN AFF Whitmore, Wh LOSS Alabama ScCo 26.0 4 26.0 3 3 OPEN Neg Brooks, S WIN Alabama MyEv 27.0 4 29.0 1 4 OPEN AFF Beaulieu, Br WIN Alabama SmAl 26.0 4 27.0 3 5 OPEN Neg Burch, Daryl WIN Alabama WyGo 27.0 2 27.0 1 6 OPEN AFF Ellinger, Ni LOSS Alabama PhGr 25.0 4 25.0 3 Georgia State Loribeth Blair & Sarah Crachiolo 1 OPEN Neg Butler, Drew LOSS Alabama ScCo 26.0 3 25.0 4 2 OPEN AFF Lee, Ed WIN Vandy StOl 26.0 3 27.0 1 3 OPEN AFF Gaston, Brya WIN Vandy ThMa 27.0 1 26.5 3 4 OPEN Neg Ellinger, Ni WIN Mercer GaWr 27.0 1 26.0 3 5 OPEN AFF Abbott, Blak LOSS Alabama MyEv 26.0 3 26.0 4 6 OPEN Neg Burch, Daryl LOSS Alabama SmAl 27.0 3 26.5 4 Georgia State Gabe Coyle & David Crawford 1 OPEN AFF Abbott, Blak LOSS Clemson LeJo 26.0 3 23.0 4 2 OPEN Neg Ellinger, Ni LOSS Alabama MyEv 27.0 2 1.0 4 3 OPEN AFF Whitmore, Wh LOSS TennTechWhCa 26.0 4 26.0 3 4 OPEN Neg Gaston, Brya WIN Vandy BoLi 27.0 2 27.0 1 5 OPEN Neg Crews, Danie LOSS Mercer GaWr 27.0 3 27.0 4 6 OPEN AFF Lee, Ed LOSS MiaFL ToRa 26.5 4 27.0 2 Louisville Loran Bernert & Ashley Helm 1 OPEN AFF Fernandez, J LOSS MiaFL ToRa 27.0 3 24.0 4 2 OPEN Neg Beaulieu, Br LOSS Mercer BeCi 28.0 3 27.0 4 3 OPEN Bye 4 OPEN AFF Abbott, Blak LOSS Capital RaJo 27.0 3 27.0 4 5 OPEN Neg Bond, Terran LOSS TennTechWhCa 27.5 3 27.0 4 6 OPEN AFF Steinberg, D LOSS Mercer GaWr 27.0 2 26.0 4 Miami (Florida) Stephanie Torre & Nate Radius 1 OPEN Neg Fernandez, J WIN L'Ville BeHe 27.5 1 27.0 2 2 OPEN AFF Burch, Daryl WIN TennTechWhCa 27.0 1 26.5 2 3 OPEN AFF Abbott, Blak LOSS Alabama WyGo 26.0 3 26.0 4 4 OPEN Neg Campbell, Br LOSS Alabama PhGr 27.0 3 27.0 4 5 OPEN AFF Brooks, S LOSS Vandy BoLi 29.0 3 27.0 4 6 OPEN Neg Lee, Ed WIN Ga St. CoCr 28.0 1 27.0 3 Tennessee Tech James Wheeler & Anne Canavan 1 OPEN AFF Young, Lynds LOSS Alabama SmAl 26.5 4 26.5 3 2 OPEN Neg Burch, Daryl LOSS MiaFL ToRa 26.0 4 26.0 3 3 OPEN Neg Whitmore, Wh WIN Ga St. CoCr 26.5 2 26.5 1 4 OPEN Bye 5 OPEN AFF Bond, Terran WIN L'Ville BeHe 28.0 2 28.5 1 6 OPEN Neg Schaerrer, M LOSS Alabama MyEv 27.0 4 27.0 3 Vanderbilt Melissa Stanley & Kim Olvey 1 OPEN AFF Campbell, Br LOSS Mercer BeCi 27.0 3 27.0 4 2 OPEN Neg Lee, Ed LOSS Ga St. BlCr 26.0 4 26.5 2 3 OPEN Fft Herndon, Jam LOSS L'Ville BeHe .0 0 .0 0 Vanderbilt Nik Botkin & Jonathan Lindsey 1 OPEN AFF Schaerrer, M LOSS Alabama WyGo 27.0 4 27.0 3 2 OPEN Neg Young, Lynds LOSS Capital PiKo 26.5 4 27.0 3 3 OPEN Neg Butler, Drew LOSS Capital RaJo 26.0 4 26.0 3 4 OPEN AFF Gaston, Brya LOSS Ga St. CoCr 27.0 4 27.0 3 5 OPEN Neg Brooks, S WIN MiaFL ToRa 30.0 1 29.0 2 6 OPEN Bye Vanderbilt Geoffrey Threlkeld & Shaun Mahaffy 1 OPEN AFF Burch, Daryl LOSS Capital PiKo 27.0 3 27.0 4 2 OPEN Neg Dillard, Tif LOSS Alabama PhGr 27.0 4 27.5 3 3 OPEN Neg Gaston, Brya LOSS Ga St. BlCr 26.0 4 26.5 2 4 OPEN AFF Butler, Drew LOSS Alabama MyEv 26.0 4 26.0 3 5 OPEN Bye 6 OPEN AFF Herndon, Jam WIN Capital RaJo 28.0 1 28.0 2 Appalachian State Matthew Hensley & Christina Todlock 1 Nov Neg Tajima, Nori LOSS Vandy PaSp 26.0 4 29.0 1 2 Nov AFF Jones, Eliza LOSS Vandy FlRy 27.0 4 28.0 2 3 Nov AFF Boydston, La WIN L'Ville FlFa 27.0 3 28.0 1 4 Nov Neg Crews, Danie WIN L'Ville JaFl 29.0 2 30.0 1 5 Nov Neg Butler, Drew WIN L'Ville BaLe 25.0 4 25.0 1 6 Nov AFF Beaulieu, Br WIN L'Ville BrSm 28.0 2 29.0 1 Quarters AFF:AppSt HeTo NEG:Vandy PaSp Schaerrer, M(NEG) Miller, David(NEG) Gaston, Bryan(NEG) Capital Angie Naugle & Nick Bates 1 Nov AFF Herndon, Jam WIN L'Ville JaFl 27.0 2 27.0 1 2 Nov Neg Fernandez, J LOSS L'Ville BaLe 27.0 3 27.5 2 3 Nov Neg Colston, Nic LOSS Vandy CrMa 27.0 4 27.0 2 4 Nov AFF Whitmore, Wh LOSS L'Ville BrSm 27.0 4 27.0 3 5 Nov AFF Boydston, La WIN L'Ville CaDu 27.0 3 27.0 1 6 Nov Neg Jones, Eliza WIN Vandy PaSp 27.0 4 28.5 1 Quarters AFF:Vandy FlRy NEG:Capital NaBa Burch, Daryl(NEG) Doggett, Matt(AFF) Crews, Daniel(AFF) Capital Adam Moore & Jen Moonie 1 Nov Neg Bond, Terran WIN L'Ville CaDu 27.0 3 28.0 1 2 Nov AFF Moore, Lisa WIN L'Ville BrSm 22.0 3 24.0 1 3 Nov Neg Thomason, Ad WIN L'Ville DeFr 28.0 4 30.0 1 4 Nov AFF Brooks, S LOSS Vandy PeHa 27.0 4 28.0 1 5 Nov AFF Tajima, Nori LOSS MiaFL CaZw 27.0 4 28.0 3 6 Nov Neg Gaston, Brya WIN L'Ville JaFl 27.0 4 29.0 2 Quarters AFF:Vandy PeHa NEG:Capital MoMo Colston, Nichole(NEG) Butler, Drew(NEG) Moore, Tim(NEG) Semis AFF:Vandy CrMa NEG:Capital MoMo Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Louisville Derenoncourt & Lucas Frazier 1 Nov Neg Grindy, Matt LOSS L'Ville MiHa 26.5 4 26.5 3 2 Nov AFF Moore, Tim LOSS MiaFL CaZw 22.0 4 23.0 3 3 Nov AFF Thomason, Ad LOSS Capital MoMo 28.0 3 29.0 2 4 Nov Neg Tajima, Nori LOSS Vandy FlRy 27.0 4 29.0 2 5 Nov Bye 6 Nov Neg Whitmore, Wh LOSS Vandy CrMa 23.0 4 23.0 3 Louisville Orion Bazzell & Lonnota Lee 1 Nov Neg Beaulieu, Br LOSS MiaFL CaZw 27.0 3 26.0 4 2 Nov AFF Fernandez, J WIN Capital NaBa 28.0 1 26.0 4 3 Nov Neg Tajima, Nori LOSS Vandy PeHa 28.0 3 26.0 4 4 Nov AFF Grindy, Matt LOSS Vandy CrMa 27.0 3 27.0 4 5 Nov AFF Butler, Drew LOSS AppSt HeTo 25.0 2 25.0 3 6 Nov Bye Louisville Karl Ballard & Lance West 1 Nov Bye Louisville Staci Brittle & Ricky Smith 1 Nov AFF Moore, Tim WIN Vandy CrMa 20.0 1 20.0 2 2 Nov Neg Moore, Lisa LOSS Capital MoMo 21.0 4 23.0 2 3 Nov AFF Bond, Terran LOSS Vandy FlRy 27.0 3 26.0 4 4 Nov Neg Whitmore, Wh WIN Capital NaBa 27.0 1 27.0 2 5 Nov AFF Pelham, T.g. LOSS Vandy PaSp 26.5 3 26.0 4 6 Nov Neg Beaulieu, Br LOSS AppSt HeTo 27.0 3 26.0 4 Louisville Andrea Huston & Stephanie Ford 1 Nov Fft Gaston, Brya LOSS Vandy FlRy .0 0 .0 0 Louisville Ebony Floyd & Natasha Fain 1 Nov Neg Moore, Lisa LOSS Vandy PeHa 22.0 3 21.0 4 2 Nov AFF Campbell, Br LOSS Vandy PaSp 28.0 4 28.0 3 3 Nov Neg Boydston, La LOSS AppSt HeTo 26.0 4 27.0 2 4 Nov Bye 5 Nov AFF Gaston, Brya WIN Vandy CrMa 29.5 2 30.0 1 6 Nov Neg Doggett, Mat LOSS MiaFL CaZw 26.0 2 24.0 4 Louisville Herbert Casey & J. Von Dukes 1 Nov AFF Bond, Terran LOSS Capital MoMo 28.0 2 27.0 4 2 Nov Neg Butler, Drew LOSS Vandy CrMa 25.0 4 25.0 3 3 Nov Bye 4 Nov AFF Miller, Davi LOSS MiaFL CaZw 24.0 3 23.0 4 5 Nov Neg Boydston, La LOSS Capital NaBa 27.0 2 27.0 4 6 Nov AFF Pelham, T.g. LOSS Vandy PeHa 26.5 4 27.0 3 Louisville Candice Miles & Jennifer Haris 1 Nov AFF Grindy, Matt WIN L'Ville DeFr 27.0 2 28.0 1 2 Nov Bye 3 Nov Neg Crews, Danie LOSS MiaFL CaZw 27.0 4 29.0 2 4 Nov AFF Herndon, Jam LOSS Vandy PaSp 28.0 4 28.0 3 5 Nov Neg Miller, Davi LOSS Vandy PeHa 23.0 3 22.0 4 6 Nov AFF Butler, Drew LOSS Vandy FlRy 25.0 3 25.0 4 Miami (Florida) Aubrie Campbell & Skylar Zwick 1 Nov AFF Beaulieu, Br WIN L'Ville BaLe 29.0 1 28.0 2 2 Nov Neg Moore, Tim WIN L'Ville DeFr 24.0 2 26.0 1 3 Nov AFF Crews, Danie WIN L'Ville MiHa 28.0 3 30.0 1 4 Nov Neg Miller, Davi WIN L'Ville CaDu 25.0 2 26.0 1 5 Nov Neg Tajima, Nori WIN Capital MoMo 28.0 2 29.0 1 6 Nov AFF Doggett, Mat WIN L'Ville FlFa 25.0 3 27.0 1 Quarters AFF:MiaFL CaZw NEG:Vandy CrMa Campbell, Brian(NEG) Jones, Elizabeth(NEG) Tajima, Nori(AFF) Vanderbilt Christine Parker & Sarah Spear 1 Nov AFF Tajima, Nori WIN AppSt HeTo 28.0 3 28.0 2 2 Nov Neg Campbell, Br WIN L'Ville FlFa 28.0 1 28.0 2 3 Nov AFF Doggett, Mat WIN L'Ville JaFl 26.0 1 24.0 3 4 Nov Neg Herndon, Jam WIN L'Ville MiHa 28.5 1 28.5 2 5 Nov Neg Pelham, T.g. WIN L'Ville BrSm 27.5 1 27.0 2 6 Nov AFF Jones, Eliza LOSS Capital NaBa 28.0 3 28.0 2 Quarters AFF:AppSt HeTo NEG:Vandy PaSp Schaerrer, M(NEG) Miller, David(NEG) Gaston, Bryan(NEG) Semis close-out; no debate. Vanderbilt Nikhil Perumbeti & Schott Hangauer 1 Nov AFF Moore, Lisa WIN L'Ville FlFa 25.0 1 23.0 2 2 Nov Neg Bond, Terran WIN L'Ville JaFl 26.0 4 27.0 2 3 Nov AFF Tajima, Nori WIN L'Ville BaLe 29.0 1 28.0 2 4 Nov Neg Brooks, S WIN Capital MoMo 28.0 2 27.0 3 5 Nov AFF Miller, Davi WIN L'Ville MiHa 24.0 2 25.0 1 6 Nov Neg Pelham, T.g. WIN L'Ville CaDu 27.5 1 27.0 2 Quarters AFF:Vandy PeHa NEG:Capital MoMo Colston, Nichole(NEG) Butler, Drew(NEG) Moore, Tim(NEG) Vanderbilt Juliet Crupi & Susan Mader 1 Nov Neg Moore, Tim LOSS L'Ville BrSm 20.0 4 20.0 3 2 Nov AFF Butler, Drew WIN L'Ville CaDu 25.0 1 25.0 2 3 Nov AFF Colston, Nic WIN Capital NaBa 28.0 1 28.0 3 4 Nov Neg Grindy, Matt WIN L'Ville BaLe 28.0 1 27.0 2 5 Nov Neg Gaston, Brya LOSS L'Ville FlFa 29.0 4 29.0 3 6 Nov AFF Whitmore, Wh WIN L'Ville DeFr 25.0 1 24.0 2 Quarters AFF:MiaFL CaZw NEG:Vandy CrMa Campbell, Brian(NEG) Jones, Elizabeth(NEG) Tajima, Nori(AFF) Semis AFF:Vandy CrMa NEG:Capital MoMo Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Finals: AFF:Vandy CrMa NEG:Vandy FlRy close-out; no debate. Vanderbilt Skip Flenniken & Katie Ryzoc 1 Nov Bye 2 Nov Neg Jones, Eliza WIN AppSt HeTo 28.5 1 28.0 3 3 Nov Neg Bond, Terran WIN L'Ville BrSm 28.0 1 27.0 2 4 Nov AFF Tajima, Nori WIN L'Ville DeFr 29.0 1 28.0 3 5 Nov AFF Colston, Nic WIN L'Ville JaFl 30.0 1 30.0 3 6 Nov Neg Butler, Drew WIN L'Ville MiHa 25.0 1 25.0 2 Quarters AFF:Vandy FlRy NEG:Capital NaBa Burch, Daryl(NEG) Doggett, Matt(AFF) Crews, Daniel(AFF) Semis close-out; no debate. Finals: AFF:Vandy CrMa NEG:Vandy FlRy close-out; no debate. Louisville Lagena James & Lilybelle Flint 1 Nov Neg Herndon, Jam LOSS Capital NaBa 26.0 4 26.0 3 2 Nov AFF Bond, Terran LOSS Vandy PeHa 27.0 3 28.0 1 3 Nov Neg Doggett, Mat LOSS Vandy PaSp 23.0 4 25.0 2 4 Nov AFF Crews, Danie LOSS AppSt HeTo 23.0 4 28.0 3 5 Nov Neg Colston, Nic LOSS Vandy FlRy 30.0 2 28.0 4 6 Nov AFF Gaston, Brya LOSS Capital MoMo 29.0 1 27.0 3