Vermont Logic & Love Debates 12-13 October 2002 University of Vermont Elim results for OPEN Finals: Rochstr LoSu advances over Rochstr MaD' without a debate. Semis: Rochstr LoSu advances over Rochstr LaVe without a debate. Semis: Rochstr MaD' defeats Vermont HiCo 3-0 Elim results for JV Elim results for Nov Finals: Rochstr SpDe defeats SUNYBingMaKl 3-2 Semis: Rochstr SpDe defeats Vermont ReWe 2-1 Semis: SUNYBingMaKl defeats Vermont VaVe 3-0 Quarters: SUNYBingMaKl defeats Vermont O'Va 3-0 Quarters: Vermont VaVe advances over Vermont PeMa without a debate. Quarters: Rochstr SpDe defeats SUNYBingGuKa 2-1 Quarters: Vermont ReWe defeats SUNYBingMaSa 3-0 Elim results for Rookie Marist College Stephen Nocera & Olivia Haley 1 OPEN Neg Jacobas, Dav WIN Vermont WiBr 27.0 1 27.0 2 2 OPEN AFF Vik Keenan LOSS Vermont HiCo 27.0 2 26.0 4 3 OPEN Neg Shawn Wilker LOSS Rochstr MaD' 28.0 4 28.0 3 4 OPEN AFF Trebilcock, LOSS Rochstr LoSu 27.5 1 27.5 2 5 OPEN AFF Parmett, Jus LOSS Rochstr NuOu 28.0 2 28.0 4 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Nafees Nuruddin & Karim Oussayef 1 OPEN Neg Green, Rebec LOSS Vermont HiCo 27.5 4 28.5 2 2 OPEN AFF Prabhu, Anoo WIN Vermont WiBr 27.5 1 27.5 2 3 OPEN Neg Morgan, Hele LOSS NYU  Mo 27.5 2 27.0 4 4 OPEN AFF Schatz, Joe WIN Vermont LaKn 29.0 1 27.0 4 5 OPEN Neg Parmett, Jus WIN Marist NoHa 28.0 1 28.0 3 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Tom Marples & Stephen D'Amico 1 OPEN AFF Trebilcock, WIN Marist GaGa 27.0 4 28.5 1 2 OPEN Neg Sweeney WIN Fordham ChJa 28.0 2 28.0 1 3 OPEN AFF Shawn Wilker WIN Marist NoHa 28.0 2 28.5 1 4 OPEN Neg Prabhu, Anoo LOSS Vermont HiCo 28.0 4 28.5 2 5 OPEN Neg Green, Rebec WIN Vermont LaKn 28.0 3 28.5 1 Semis AFF:Rochstr MaD' NEG:Vermont HiCo Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Finals: AFF:Rochstr LoSu NEG:Rochstr MaD' close-out; no debate. Fordham University Asha Cherian & Sean Jacques 1 OPEN AFF Shawn Wilker WIN GoYu 28.0 1 27.5 2 2 OPEN AFF Sweeney LOSS Rochstr MaD' 25.0 4 25.0 3 3 OPEN Neg Merrill, Joh LOSS Rochstr LoSu 27.0 4 27.5 3 4 OPEN AFF Morgan, Hele LOSS Rochstr LaVe 27.5 2 27.0 3 5 OPEN Bye Vermont Lana Langsweirdt & Jen Knops 1 OPEN Neg Prabhu, Anoo LOSS Rochstr LoSu 28.0 2 27.5 4 2 OPEN AFF Ketsdever, N WIN GoYu 27.5 2 27.5 1 3 OPEN AFF Schnurer, Ma WIN Rochstr GaMo 28.5 1 27.0 3 4 OPEN Neg Schatz, Joe LOSS Rochstr NuOu 29.0 2 28.5 3 5 OPEN AFF Green, Rebec LOSS Rochstr MaD' 28.5 2 28.0 4 Vermont Teresa Hill & Brian Cole 1 OPEN AFF Green, Rebec WIN Rochstr NuOu 28.0 1 28.0 3 2 OPEN Neg Vik Keenan WIN Marist NoHa 27.5 1 27.0 3 3 OPEN Neg Maritato, Ji WIN Rochstr LaVe 29.0 1 28.0 2 4 OPEN AFF Prabhu, Anoo WIN Rochstr MaD' 28.5 1 28.0 3 5 OPEN AFF Schatz, Joe LOSS Rochstr LoSu 28.5 2 28.0 3 Semis AFF:Rochstr MaD' NEG:Vermont HiCo Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Cedric Logan & Rajen Subramanian 1 OPEN AFF Prabhu, Anoo WIN Vermont LaKn 27.5 3 28.0 1 2 OPEN Neg Shawn Wilker WIN Marist GaGa 28.5 1 27.5 3 3 OPEN AFF Merrill, Joh WIN Fordham ChJa 29.5 1 29.0 2 4 OPEN Neg Trebilcock, WIN Marist NoHa 27.0 3 27.0 4 5 OPEN Neg Schatz, Joe WIN Vermont HiCo 27.0 4 28.5 1 Semis AFF:Rochstr LoSu NEG:Rochstr LaVe close-out; no debate. Finals: AFF:Rochstr LoSu NEG:Rochstr MaD' close-out; no debate. Vermont Carlos Varela & Leo Velez 1 Nov AFF Myers, Jessi WIN Fordham PiKo 26.5 2 27.5 1 2 Nov Neg Merrill, Joh LOSS SUNYBingGuKa 27.0 4 28.0 1 3 Nov AFF Green, Rebec WIN Rochstr LiPl 26.0 4 27.0 1 4 Nov Neg Rubino, Kath WIN SUNYBingNeSe 26.5 2 27.5 1 5 Nov AFF Lee, Adam WIN Fordham EvMa 27.0 3 29.0 1 Quarters AFF:Vermont VaVe NEG:Vermont PeMa close-out; no debate. Semis AFF:SUNYBingMaKl NEG:Vermont VaVe Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Vermont Tim Reimer & Christine Welch 1 Nov Neg Vik Keenan WIN Rochstr TsPo 27.5 1 26.5 2 2 Nov AFF Maritato, Ji WIN SUNYBingNeSe 25.0 2 26.0 1 3 Nov AFF Ketsdever, N WIN Fordham EvMa 27.0 3 27.5 1 4 Nov Neg Schnurer, Ma WIN Rochstr KaKi 28.0 2 28.0 1 5 Nov Neg Erin O'Brien LOSS SUNYBingMaSa 27.0 3 28.0 2 Quarters AFF:Vermont ReWe NEG:SUNYBingMaSa Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Semis AFF:Rochstr SpDe NEG:Vermont ReWe Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Vermont Ryan O'Connor & Amy Vaillancourt 1 Nov Neg Erin O'Brien WIN Marist Ha1 27.0 1 27.0 2 2 Nov AFF Schatz, Joe WIN Rochstr KiOs 24.0 4 26.5 1 3 Nov AFF Webster WIN SUNYBingNeSe 27.5 1 27.0 3 4 Nov Neg Myers, Jessi WIN Marist LoGr 27.0 2 27.0 1 5 Nov Neg Hewitt, Rach LOSS SUNYBingGuKa 25.0 3 23.0 4 Quarters AFF:SUNYBingMaKl NEG:Vermont O'Va Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Vermont Sharyani Mukherjee & Michael Malone 1 Nov Neg Ketsdever, N LOSS SUNYBingNeSe 28.0 1 28.0 2 2 Nov AFF Webster LOSS Fordham EvMa 27.5 2 27.0 3 3 Nov AFF Jacobas, Dav LOSS Marist LoGr 27.0 2 26.0 4 4 Nov Neg Hewitt, Rach LOSS Marist Ha1 25.0 2 25.0 3 5 Nov Bye Vermont Cody Rounds & Lindsey Melander 1 Nov Neg Hewitt, Rach WIN Fordham EvMa 26.0 3 27.0 2 2 Nov AFF Lee, Adam LOSS Marist LoGr 26.5 4 26.5 2 3 Nov Neg Ellis, Andy LOSS Rochstr KiOs 28.0 2 27.0 3 4 Nov AFF Merrill, Joh LOSS SUNYBingMaKl 27.0 4 27.0 3 5 Nov Neg Webster WIN Marist PePh 27.0 3 28.0 1 Vermont Sarah Ptalis & Oliver Matthews 1 Nov Bye 2 Nov AFF Myers, Jessi LOSS SUNYBingMaSa 27.0 2 27.0 1 3 Nov Neg Hewitt, Rach WIN HeDa 27.0 4 29.0 1 4 Nov AFF Webster LOSS SUNYBingGuKa 27.5 3 27.5 4 5 Nov AFF Ketsdever, N LOSS Fordham PiKo 27.5 2 27.5 3 Vermont Eric Mates & Whitney Smith 1 Nov Neg Schatz, Joe WIN Marist LoGr 25.0 3 26.0 2 2 Nov AFF Hewitt, Rach WIN Rochstr TsPo 25.0 3 27.0 1 3 Nov AFF Vik Keenan WIN Fordham PiKo 26.0 2 26.5 1 4 Nov Neg Erin O'Brien LOSS Fordham EvMa 27.0 3 28.0 2 5 Nov Neg Rubino, Kath WIN Rochstr KiOs 27.0 1 26.0 2 SUNY-Binghamton Stephanie Mack & Ronald Klein 1 Nov Neg Jillian Mart WIN Rochstr KiOs 28.5 1 28.0 2 2 Nov AFF Mcdonald, St WIN Rochstr LiPl 29.0 1 29.0 2 3 Nov AFF Meany, Jake WIN Rochstr KaKi 27.0 2 27.0 1 4 Nov Neg Merrill, Joh WIN Vermont RoMe 27.5 2 29.0 1 5 Nov AFF Edwin Owusu WIN Rochstr SpDe 28.5 1 27.0 3 Quarters AFF:SUNYBingMaKl NEG:Vermont O'Va Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Semis AFF:SUNYBingMaKl NEG:Vermont VaVe Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Finals: AFF:Rochstr SpDe NEG:SUNYBingMaKl Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Unknown(NEG) Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Hyung-joon Kim & Opemipo Osoba 1 Nov AFF Jillian Mart LOSS SUNYBingMaKl 26.0 3 26.0 4 2 Nov Neg Schatz, Joe LOSS Vermont O'Va 26.0 2 25.0 3 3 Nov AFF Ellis, Andy WIN Vermont RoMe 28.0 1 27.0 4 4 Nov Neg Egizi LOSS Fordham PiKo 26.5 3 26.0 4 5 Nov AFF Rubino, Kath LOSS Vermont MaSm 25.0 3 25.0 4 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) David Kang & Ailleen Kim 1 Nov AFF Hellmuth WIN HeDa 29.0 1 27.0 3 2 Nov Bye 3 Nov Neg Meany, Jake LOSS SUNYBingMaKl 26.0 3 26.0 4 4 Nov AFF Schnurer, Ma LOSS Vermont ReWe 27.0 3 27.0 4 5 Nov Neg Jacobas, Dav LOSS Vermont PeMa 25.0 4 25.0 3 Marist College Matt Gardner & Jacqui Gamrat 1 OPEN Neg Rubino, Kath LOSS Rochstr MaD' 27.0 3 27.5 2 2 OPEN AFF Shawn Wilker LOSS Rochstr LoSu 27.0 4 27.5 2 3 OPEN Neg Myers, Jessi WIN GoYu 26.0 1 26.0 2 4 OPEN AFF Ketsdever, N WIN NYU  Mo 26.0 4 27.0 2 5 OPEN Neg Trebilcock, WIN Rochstr LaVe 27.0 3 28.0 2 SUNY-Binghamton Sara Manfro & Michelle Sakhaee 1 Nov AFF Sweeney LOSS Rochstr SpDe 24.0 3 24.0 4 2 Nov Neg Myers, Jessi WIN Vermont PtMa 26.0 3 26.0 4 3 Nov AFF Hellmuth WIN Marist Ha1 28.0 1 27.0 4 4 Nov Neg Shawn Wilker WIN Marist PePh 28.5 2 28.0 4 5 Nov AFF Erin O'Brien WIN Vermont ReWe 29.0 1 26.0 4 Quarters AFF:Vermont ReWe NEG:SUNYBingMaSa Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Theresa Spaulding & Emily Desmond 1 Nov Neg Sweeney WIN SUNYBingMaSa 27.0 2 29.0 1 2 Nov Bye 3 Nov Bye 4 Nov Neg Maritato, Ji WIN Vermont PeMa 26.0 2 27.0 1 5 Nov Neg Edwin Owusu LOSS SUNYBingMaKl 27.5 4 28.5 2 Quarters AFF:Rochstr SpDe NEG:SUNYBingGuKa Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Semis AFF:Rochstr SpDe NEG:Vermont ReWe Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Finals: AFF:Rochstr SpDe NEG:SUNYBingMaKl Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) Unknown(NEG) Marist College Suzanne Lo & Dierdre Greeley 1 Nov AFF Schatz, Joe LOSS Vermont MaSm 26.0 1 24.0 4 2 Nov Neg Lee, Adam WIN Vermont RoMe 27.0 1 26.5 3 3 Nov Neg Jacobas, Dav WIN Vermont MuMa 26.0 3 27.0 1 4 Nov AFF Myers, Jessi LOSS Vermont O'Va 26.5 3 26.5 4 5 Nov Neg Hellmuth WIN Rochstr LiPl 30.0 1 29.0 3 Vermont Jill Witney & Shana Bryce 1 OPEN AFF Jacobas, Dav LOSS Marist NoHa 26.0 3 26.0 4 2 OPEN Neg Prabhu, Anoo LOSS Rochstr NuOu 27.0 4 27.0 3 3 OPEN Bye 4 OPEN Neg Ellis, Andy LOSS Rochstr GaMo 27.0 4 28.0 2 5 OPEN Neg Maritato, Ji LOSS NYU  Mo 26.0 3 25.0 4 New York Univ. Joseph Philip   & Danyaal Moin 1 OPEN Neg Ellis, Andy LOSS Rochstr LaVe 28.0 3 28.0 2 2 OPEN AFF Trebilcock, WIN Rochstr GaMo 27.5 3 27.5 2 3 OPEN AFF Morgan, Hele WIN Rochstr NuOu 27.0 3 28.0 1 4 OPEN Neg Ketsdever, N LOSS Marist GaGa 26.5 3 27.5 1 5 OPEN AFF Maritato, Ji WIN Vermont WiBr 26.5 2 27.0 1 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Liz Gaskell & Michael Morosi 1 OPEN Bye 2 OPEN Neg Trebilcock, LOSS NYU  Mo 28.0 1 27.0 4 3 OPEN Neg Schnurer, Ma LOSS Vermont LaKn 27.5 2 26.5 4 4 OPEN AFF Ellis, Andy WIN Vermont WiBr 28.0 1 27.0 3 5 OPEN Neg Merrill, Joh WIN GoYu 29.0 2 29.0 1 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Jonathan Laine & John Vermitsky 1 OPEN AFF Ellis, Andy WIN NYU  Mo 28.0 4 28.5 1 2 OPEN Bye 3 OPEN AFF Maritato, Ji LOSS Vermont HiCo 27.0 4 28.0 3 4 OPEN Neg Morgan, Hele WIN Fordham ChJa 27.0 4 28.5 1 5 OPEN AFF Trebilcock, LOSS Marist GaGa 27.0 4 29.0 1 Semis AFF:Rochstr LoSu NEG:Rochstr LaVe close-out; no debate. Middlebury College Mark Douglas & Drew Pugsley 2 OPEN Fft Jacobas, Dav LOSS Rochstr LaVe .0 0 .0 0 Massachusetts Dennis Gove & Chris Yu 1 OPEN Neg Shawn Wilker LOSS Fordham ChJa 27.0 4 27.0 3 2 OPEN Neg Ketsdever, N LOSS Vermont LaKn 26.5 4 26.5 3 3 OPEN AFF Myers, Jessi LOSS Marist GaGa 26.0 4 26.0 3 4 OPEN Bye 5 OPEN AFF Merrill, Joh LOSS Rochstr GaMo 26.0 4 26.0 3 Vermont Chris Pettrone & Kayce Massey 1 Nov Neg Merrill, Joh WIN Rochstr LiPl 27.0 2 27.0 1 2 Nov Neg Green, Rebec WIN HeDa 28.0 1 27.5 3 3 Nov Neg Schatz, Joe WIN Rochstr TsPo 27.0 1 26.0 2 4 Nov AFF Maritato, Ji LOSS Rochstr SpDe 25.0 3 24.0 4 5 Nov AFF Jacobas, Dav WIN Rochstr KaKi 27.0 2 28.0 1 Quarters AFF:Vermont VaVe NEG:Vermont PeMa close-out; no debate. Vermont Justin Linder & Rob Hunt Fordham University Vince Evans & Reggie Martin 1 Nov AFF Hewitt, Rach LOSS Vermont RoMe 29.0 1 26.0 4 2 Nov Neg Webster WIN Vermont MuMa 27.5 1 27.0 4 3 Nov Neg Ketsdever, N LOSS Vermont ReWe 27.0 2 26.5 4 4 Nov AFF Erin O'Brien WIN Vermont MaSm 28.0 1 26.0 4 5 Nov Neg Lee, Adam LOSS Vermont VaVe 28.0 2 26.0 4 Massachusetts Bridget Henry & Andrea Davulis 1 Nov Neg Hellmuth LOSS Rochstr KaKi 27.0 4 28.0 2 2 Nov AFF Green, Rebec LOSS Vermont PeMa 27.5 2 27.0 4 3 Nov AFF Hewitt, Rach LOSS Vermont PtMa 28.0 2 27.0 3 4 Nov Neg Meany, Jake LOSS Rochstr LiPl 26.0 4 26.0 3 5 Nov Neg Shawn Wilker LOSS Rochstr TsPo 27.5 2 27.5 3 Marist College Megan Peak & Kristin Phillips 1 Nov AFF Mcdonald, St WIN SUNYBingGuKa 28.0 2 28.0 1 2 Nov Neg Erin O'Brien LOSS Fordham PiKo 27.0 2 26.0 4 3 Nov Fft Parmett, Jus LOSS Rochstr SpDe .0 0 .0 0 4 Nov AFF Shawn Wilker LOSS SUNYBingMaSa 29.0 1 28.0 3 5 Nov AFF Webster LOSS Vermont RoMe 28.0 2 27.0 4 Marist College Matt Hannon & Any Debater 1 (HYBRID) 1 Nov AFF Erin O'Brien LOSS Vermont O'Va 25.0 3 25.0 4 2 Nov Fft Jillian Mart LOSS Rochstr SpDe .0 0 .0 0 3 Nov Neg Hellmuth LOSS SUNYBingMaSa 28.0 2 28.0 3 4 Nov AFF Hewitt, Rach WIN Vermont MuMa 26.0 1 25.0 4 5 Nov AFF Mcdonald, St WIN SUNYBingNeSe 29.0 1 27.0 4 SUNY-Binghamton Ravi Gupta & Glenn Kates 1 Nov Neg Mcdonald, St LOSS Marist PePh 25.0 3 20.0 4 2 Nov AFF Merrill, Joh WIN Vermont VaVe 27.0 3 27.0 2 3 Nov Bye 4 Nov Neg Webster WIN Vermont PtMa 28.0 2 28.0 1 5 Nov AFF Hewitt, Rach WIN Vermont O'Va 26.0 2 27.0 1 Quarters AFF:Rochstr SpDe NEG:SUNYBingGuKa Unknown(AFF) Unknown(AFF) Unknown(NEG) SUNY-Binghamton Gregory Nep & Amanda Sedaca-Rosenberg 1 Nov AFF Ketsdever, N WIN Vermont MuMa 27.5 3 27.0 4 2 Nov Neg Maritato, Ji LOSS Vermont ReWe 20.0 4 23.0 3 3 Nov Neg Webster LOSS Vermont O'Va 27.0 2 27.0 4 4 Nov AFF Rubino, Kath LOSS Vermont VaVe 24.0 4 25.0 3 5 Nov Neg Mcdonald, St LOSS Marist Ha1 28.0 3 28.0 2 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Tina Tsao & Ashley Poelma 1 Nov AFF Vik Keenan LOSS Vermont ReWe 26.0 3 25.0 4 2 Nov Neg Hewitt, Rach LOSS Vermont MaSm 24.0 4 25.0 2 3 Nov AFF Schatz, Joe LOSS Vermont PeMa 25.0 4 25.0 3 4 Nov Bye 5 Nov AFF Shawn Wilker WIN HeDa 27.0 4 28.0 1 Rochester (Univ. of Rochester) Ben Lin & Anthony Plan 1 Nov AFF Merrill, Joh LOSS Vermont PeMa 26.5 4 27.0 3 2 Nov Neg Mcdonald, St LOSS SUNYBingMaKl 27.0 3 25.0 4 3 Nov Neg Green, Rebec LOSS Vermont VaVe 26.0 3 26.0 2 4 Nov AFF Meany, Jake WIN HeDa 28.0 1 26.0 2 5 Nov AFF Hellmuth LOSS Marist LoGr 30.0 2 28.0 4 Fordham University Marianne Pichushykina & Craig Konnoth 1 Nov Neg Myers, Jessi LOSS Vermont VaVe 26.0 4 26.0 3 2 Nov AFF Erin O'Brien WIN Marist PePh 26.0 3 28.0 1 3 Nov Neg Vik Keenan LOSS Vermont MaSm 24.0 4 26.0 3 4 Nov AFF Egizi WIN Rochstr KiOs 27.0 2 27.5 1 5 Nov Neg Ketsdever, N WIN Vermont PtMa 27.5 4 28.0 1